Amish desserts are renowned for their simplicity, natural ingredients, and homespun charm. Rooted in a tradition that values hard work and minimalism, Amish recipes often rely on basic pantry staples to create hearty, delicious sweets. These desserts, like the culture they come from, emphasize the importance of quality over complexity. Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is a perfect example of this ethos—offering rich, comforting flavors without requiring elaborate techniques or exotic ingredients.

The unique appeal of Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie lies in its combination of creamy filling and crumbly texture. The pie’s layers—consisting of peanut butter crumbles, smooth vanilla-pudding-based peanut butter filling, and fluffy whipped cream—create a perfect balance of sweet, salty, and rich flavors. The crumbly peanut butter mixture sprinkled throughout adds an unexpected texture that makes every bite interesting and delightful.

One of the most attractive qualities of this pie is its simplicity. Even with its rich layers and satisfying texture, this recipe is surprisingly easy to make at home. It doesn’t require advanced baking skills, which makes it perfect for everyday desserts or special occasions. Whether you’re preparing a treat for a family gathering, a holiday celebration, or simply indulging in a sweet craving, Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is a versatile, crowd-pleasing dessert that’s sure to impress with its wholesome, comforting flavors.

The History of Amish Desserts

Amish culinary traditions are deeply rooted in the principles of simplicity and self-sufficiency. The Amish community, known for their agrarian lifestyle and avoidance of modern conveniences, have passed down recipes through generations that reflect their commitment to homemade, natural, and seasonal ingredients. Their desserts, in particular, often revolve around easily accessible ingredients such as butter, cream, eggs, and flour, which are typically sourced from their own farms.

Desserts hold a special place in Amish culture, frequently featured in communal gatherings and family meals. These sweets are designed to be comforting and filling, often with little adornment but packed with flavor. Pies, cakes, and cookies are the most common desserts in Amish cuisine, with pies like shoofly pie and cream pies standing out as staples.

Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is an adaptation of the traditional cream pie, with a twist that incorporates the beloved American ingredient: peanut butter. Peanut butter’s rich, nutty flavor complements the smooth texture of the cream filling, making it a perfect fit for the Amish approach to dessert. This pie also reflects the Amish preference for handmade elements—such as crumbles and whipped topping—reinforcing their belief in the importance of using natural, uncomplicated ingredients in their recipes.

• Save

Ingredients Breakdown

Pie Crust
The foundation of any pie is the crust, and Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is no exception. While you can certainly use a store-bought pie crust for convenience, making your own from scratch adds a layer of authenticity and flavor. A simple baked crust, whether it’s made with a buttery shortcrust or a flaky pastry dough, forms the base for this dessert. Pre-baking the crust ensures it remains crisp and doesn’t become soggy when the filling is added. For an even more decadent variation, a graham cracker or Oreo crust can be used, lending a sweeter, crunchier base to the pie.

Peanut Butter Crumbles
One of the standout features of Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is its peanut butter crumbles, which add a delightful texture to each bite. Made from just two ingredients—powdered sugar and creamy peanut butter—the crumbles provide a slightly sweet, crumbly contrast to the smooth filling. The secret to achieving the perfect crumble texture is to mix the ingredients until they form small, pea-sized clusters that are neither too dry nor too sticky. These crumbles are layered both on the bottom of the pie and sprinkled on top, adding a satisfying crunch to the creamy filling.

Peanut Butter Filling
The heart of the pie is its creamy peanut butter filling, which combines instant vanilla pudding mix, milk, peanut butter, and whipped cream or Cool Whip. The pudding base offers a smooth, custard-like consistency, while the peanut butter adds richness and depth of flavor. Folding in the whipped cream lightens the filling, making it airy and soft, without compromising its creamy texture. This filling strikes the perfect balance between sweetness and the savory nuttiness of peanut butter, creating a rich, indulgent layer that complements the crumbles.

Whipped Topping
Topping the pie is a layer of sweetened whipped cream or Cool Whip, adding a fluffy, light texture that balances the richness of the peanut butter filling. Homemade whipped cream offers a fresher, more natural flavor, but Cool Whip is a convenient and stable alternative that holds its shape longer. Whether you choose to spread the whipped topping in a smooth layer or pipe it decoratively, it adds the finishing touch to this delightful pie. Using high-quality ingredients, such as real cream and premium peanut butter, ensures the pie achieves the perfect texture and flavor.

Step-by-Step Recipe Instructions

Step 1: Make the Peanut Butter Crumbles
Begin by preparing the peanut butter crumbles, a key textural element of the pie. In a small bowl, mix ½ cup of powdered sugar with ¼ cup of creamy peanut butter. Stir the ingredients together with a fork or your fingers until they form small, crumbly clusters. The goal is to create a mixture that is dry enough to crumble easily, but still holds together in small pieces. If the mixture is too wet and sticky, add a bit more powdered sugar; if it’s too dry, add a small amount of peanut butter. Set these crumbles aside, as half will go on the bottom of the pie crust, and the other half will be used to top the finished pie.

Step 2: Prepare the Peanut Butter Filling
In a medium mixing bowl, whisk together one 3.4 oz package of instant vanilla pudding mix, 1 ½ cups of milk, and ½ cup of creamy peanut butter. Whisk vigorously for about two minutes until the mixture thickens. The goal is to achieve a smooth, creamy consistency without any lumps. If your peanut butter is stiff, you may want to slightly warm it in the microwave to make it easier to incorporate into the pudding mix. The thickening process will happen quickly, and the mixture should reach a rich, custard-like texture after just a couple of minutes.

Step 3: Fold in the Whipped Cream
Once the peanut butter pudding mixture is smooth and thickened, gently fold in 1 cup of whipped cream or Cool Whip. Folding involves gently stirring the whipped cream into the mixture using a spatula, in order to maintain the light, airy texture of the whipped cream. Be careful not to overmix, as this could deflate the whipped cream and make the filling denser than desired. The whipped cream lightens the texture of the filling and makes it fluffier, which is key to the pie’s creamy texture.

Step 4: Assemble the Pie
Now it’s time to assemble the pie. First, sprinkle half of the peanut butter crumbles across the bottom of the pre-baked and cooled pie crust, ensuring an even layer. Next, pour the peanut butter filling over the crumbles, spreading it evenly across the crust. The filling should cover the entire surface, but leave a little room at the top for the whipped cream layer. Once the filling is spread, top it with 2 cups of sweetened whipped cream or an 8 oz container of Cool Whip. You can either spread the whipped cream in an even layer or pipe it decoratively for a more elegant presentation.

Step 5: Refrigerate the Pie
Refrigerating the pie is a crucial step to allow it to set properly. Once assembled, place the pie in the refrigerator for at least two hours, or until the filling firms up and the flavors meld together. This resting period ensures that the pie holds its shape when sliced. Without adequate chilling time, the filling may be too soft and runny, making it difficult to cut neat slices. After the pie has set, sprinkle the remaining peanut butter crumbles on top of the whipped cream before serving.

Variations and Substitutions

Different Types of Pie Crust
For those looking to enhance the flavor or texture of the pie, there are several crust alternatives to the traditional pie crust. A graham cracker crust adds a sweet, crunchy base that complements the peanut butter filling, while an Oreo cookie crust provides a more indulgent, chocolatey option. Both alternatives require no pre-baking and are easy to prepare by mixing crushed cookies with melted butter and pressing the mixture into the pie pan.

Nut Butter Variations
Peanut butter is the star of this pie, but it can easily be substituted with other types of nut butters. Almond butter or cashew butter offer milder, slightly sweeter flavors, while sunflower seed butter is a good alternative for those with nut allergies. Keep in mind that the texture of the filling may vary slightly depending on the type of nut butter used, as some are thicker or oilier than peanut butter. Adjust the quantity of milk accordingly to maintain the right consistency.

Gluten-Free and Dairy-Free Options
To make this pie gluten-free, simply use a gluten-free pie crust or prepare a crust using gluten-free cookies. For a dairy-free version, swap out the milk with almond, soy, or oat milk, and use a dairy-free whipped topping like coconut whipped cream. Ensure that your pudding mix is also dairy-free, as some brands may contain milk-based ingredients.

Flavor Twists
For those looking to experiment with flavors, try drizzling chocolate ganache or caramel sauce over the whipped cream topping. Adding sliced bananas between the peanut butter crumbles and the filling layer introduces a fruity element, turning the pie into a peanut butter banana cream pie.

Tips for Perfecting the Pie

Chilling the Pie
One of the most important steps in this recipe is allowing the pie to chill for at least two hours. This time is necessary for the filling to firm up and set properly. Rushing this process can result in a pie that’s too soft to slice cleanly, leading to a mess when serving. For best results, you can even chill the pie overnight, allowing the flavors to meld together beautifully.

Preventing a Soggy Crust
To avoid a soggy bottom crust, ensure that your pie crust is completely cooled before adding the filling. If the crust is still warm, the filling will cause it to become mushy. Another tip is to brush the baked crust with a light layer of melted chocolate or egg white before adding the filling, creating a barrier that prevents moisture from seeping in.

Getting the Right Peanut Butter Crumble Texture
For the crumbles, make sure the ratio of powdered sugar to peanut butter is balanced. If the mixture is too sticky, the crumbles will not scatter evenly and may clump together. On the other hand, too much powdered sugar will cause the crumbles to become overly dry. Adjust as needed to get the perfect, slightly crumbly texture.

Whipped Cream Consistency
When making homemade whipped cream, beat the cream until soft peaks form, being careful not to over-whip it, as this can lead to a grainy texture. The goal is to achieve a light, fluffy topping that holds its shape but isn’t too stiff.

• Save

Serving Suggestions

To present your Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie with maximum visual appeal, consider adding decorative touches to the whipped topping. One simple method is to pipe the whipped cream using a star-shaped nozzle, creating elegant swirls or peaks around the edges of the pie. This gives the pie a polished, bakery-quality finish. For extra flair, drizzle melted peanut butter or chocolate sauce over the whipped cream in a zig-zag pattern, adding a rich contrast in both flavor and appearance. You can also garnish the pie with additional peanut butter crumbles, chocolate shavings, or even a sprinkle of sea salt for a gourmet touch.

Pairing this pie with beverages like coffee, tea, or milk enhances the eating experience. The pie’s creamy, rich peanut butter flavor goes particularly well with a strong cup of coffee or tea, balancing out its sweetness. A cold glass of milk is a classic companion that highlights the pie’s smooth texture.

This pie is perfect for special occasions such as holiday dinners, potlucks, family gatherings, or birthdays. Its familiar flavors and comforting texture make it a crowd-pleaser at events where a homemade, hearty dessert is always welcome.

Storing and Freezing the Pie

To store leftover Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie, cover it tightly with plastic wrap or place it in an airtight container. This will help maintain the freshness of the whipped topping and the integrity of the pie’s texture. The pie can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 3-4 days, but it’s best enjoyed within the first two days to ensure the crust remains crisp and the filling maintains its optimal creaminess.

While it’s possible to freeze this pie, there are some important considerations. Freezing can alter the texture of whipped cream, causing it to become grainy or watery upon thawing. If you decide to freeze the pie, wrap it in plastic wrap followed by aluminum foil, and store it for up to one month. Thaw it in the fridge overnight before serving, but keep in mind that the texture of the whipped cream and filling may not be as smooth as when freshly made.

• Save

FAQs

Can I make this pie ahead of time?
Yes! Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie can be made up to two days in advance. Simply store the pie in the refrigerator, covered tightly with plastic wrap. The extra chilling time will allow the flavors to meld together beautifully, making the pie taste even better. Just make sure to add the final layer of peanut butter crumbles right before serving to ensure they retain their texture.

Can I use natural peanut butter instead of creamy?
Yes, you can use natural peanut butter, but the texture might be slightly different. Natural peanut butter tends to be more oily and less stable than creamy peanut butter, which could affect the consistency of the crumbles and the filling. If using natural peanut butter, make sure to stir it thoroughly before adding it to the recipe, and you may need to adjust the amount of powdered sugar in the crumbles to compensate for the extra oil.

Can I use homemade whipped cream instead of Cool Whip?
Absolutely! Homemade whipped cream is a fantastic option. To make it, beat 1 cup of heavy cream with 2 tablespoons of powdered sugar until soft peaks form. Be careful not to over-whip the cream, as it can become grainy or turn into butter. Homemade whipped cream adds a fresher, more natural taste to the pie, but it will not hold its shape as long as Cool Whip, so plan to serve the pie within a day or two.

What should I do if the pie doesn’t set?
If the pie doesn’t set properly, it may be due to not whisking the pudding mix long enough or not chilling the pie for enough time. Ensure that the filling thickens during the mixing stage, and refrigerate the pie for at least two hours before serving. If it’s still too soft, try chilling it for an additional hour or two.

Can I add chocolate to this recipe?
Yes, you can easily add chocolate for extra richness. Consider folding in chocolate chips or drizzling chocolate ganache over the top. Another option is to add a layer of melted chocolate to the bottom of the pie crust before adding the crumbles and filling, creating a delicious chocolate-peanut butter combination.

• Save

Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

---

• Author: Christine

Pin Recipe

Pin Recipe

Description

This Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is a rich, indulgent dessert that blends the nutty goodness of peanut butter with a creamy, vanilla pudding filling, light whipped topping, and crunchy peanut butter crumbles. This pie is perfect for those who love a combination of textures: the crumbly peanut butter mixture adds a delightful contrast to the smooth, creamy layers. It’s a simple recipe that offers a big payoff in both taste and presentation, making it ideal for gatherings, holidays, or a special family treat.

---

Ingredients

Scale 1x2x3x

• Pie Crust: 1 pre-baked 9-inch pie crust (homemade or store-bought)
• Peanut Butter Crumbles:
  • ½ cup powdered sugar
  • ¼ cup creamy peanut butter
• Peanut Butter Filling:
  • 1 (3.4 oz) box instant vanilla pudding mix
  • 1½ cups milk
  • ½ cup creamy peanut butter
  • 1 cup whipped cream or Cool Whip
• Whipped Topping:
  • 2 cups sweetened whipped cream or 8 oz Cool Whip

---

Instructions

Step 1: Make the Peanut Butter Crumbles
In a small bowl, combine ½ cup powdered sugar and ¼ cup creamy peanut butter. Using a fork, mix them together until the mixture becomes crumbly and forms small, pea-sized clusters. Adjust with more powdered sugar or peanut butter as needed to achieve the right texture. Set aside half of the crumbles for later use.

Step 2: Prepare the Peanut Butter Filling
In a medium bowl, whisk together the instant vanilla pudding mix, 1½ cups of milk, and ½ cup of creamy peanut butter for 2 minutes, or until thickened and smooth. Make sure there are no lumps and that the mixture reaches a custard-like consistency.

Step 3: Fold in Whipped Cream
Gently fold in 1 cup of whipped cream or Cool Whip into the peanut butter pudding mixture. Use a spatula to carefully combine the whipped cream, making sure not to deflate it too much. The goal is to lighten the filling with a fluffy, airy texture.

Step 4: Assemble the Pie
Sprinkle half of the peanut butter crumbles evenly across the bottom of the pre-baked pie crust. Pour the peanut butter filling on top of the crumbles and spread it out evenly. Top the filling with 2 cups of whipped cream or Cool Whip, either spreading it smoothly or piping it decoratively across the surface.

Step 5: Refrigerate the Pie
Refrigerate the pie for at least 2 hours to allow the filling to set properly. This step is crucial for ensuring the pie holds its shape when sliced. After chilling, sprinkle the remaining peanut butter crumbles over the whipped topping just before serving.

Notes

• Peanut Butter Texture: If using natural peanut butter, be sure to stir it thoroughly before mixing it with the powdered sugar or the pudding mixture. Natural peanut butter’s higher oil content can affect the texture, so adjusting the sugar in the crumbles might be necessary.
• Homemade Whipped Cream: For a fresher alternative to Cool Whip, make homemade whipped cream by beating 1 cup heavy cream with 2 tablespoons powdered sugar until soft peaks form. This option offers a cleaner, more natural flavor, but it won’t hold its shape for as long as Cool Whip.
• Storing the Pie: Store leftovers in the fridge for up to 3-4 days, covered tightly with plastic wrap. For best results, add the final layer of peanut butter crumbles just before serving to keep them crunchy.
• Freezing the Pie: Although you can freeze this pie, note that whipped cream may not retain its texture well once thawed. If freezing, wrap the pie tightly in plastic wrap and foil, then thaw it in the fridge overnight before serving.